With fantasy draft day approaching, I am looking hard at Matt Forte second overall, and for
some reason I keep trying to think of a reason not to take him. I've taken Steven Jackson
in the first round each of the last two years, so I'm really trying to limit my risk as much
as possible. My most recent fear is that he will suffer in his second year because of the
workload he had in his rookie season.
So I checked in recent history for all RBs who had 250 rushes or 300 total touches in their
rookie season. I got 11 players, three of which were Forte, Chris Johnson and Steve Slaton,
so they were immediately removed from the list, as we don't know how their second seasons are
going to go, that's what we're trying to predict. It did however re-emphasize just how
impressive what those three RBs did last year really was.
So the remaining eight players are LaDainian Tomlinson, Jamal Lewis, Clinton Portis, Fred Taylor,
Edgerrin James, Willis McGahee, Marshawn Lynch, and Ricky Williams. Tomlinson played all 16
games both seasons. Lewis missed the entire 2001 season with a knee injury, which isn't good
news. Portis played three fewer games in his second season, from 16 down to 13. Taylor
played five fewer games, from 15 to 10. James played all 16 games both years. McGahee actually
played one more game his second season, from 15 to 16 games. Lynch played two more games in
his second season, from 13 to 15. Finally, Williams played two fewer games, from 12 down to
10 games.
Overall, Jamal Lewis was a big loss, and Fred Taylor's five games were also considerable, but
there was no strong trend as only two of the eight players missed considerably more time.
Half of the eight did play fewer games though, so there should be some concern. Let's look
at what's more important; their statistical output. Obvsiously Lewis didn't repeat his rookie
season's numbers of over 1600 total yards and six TDs as he didn't play.
Fred Taylor, the other player to miss significant time, also saw his numbers drop. He had 139
fewer touches, 829 fewer yards, and 11 fewer TDs, serious dents in his production. Lewis and
Taylor raise some big red flags with their sophomore slumps. But that is where the slumps
end in our little study.
Despite there being two more players who played fewer games, all six remaining players had as
many or more touches in their second season. Marshawn Lynch had as many touches in his second
year as in his rookie year, with 29 fewer carries and 29 more receptions.
Each of the six players had more yards in their second season, with the smallest jump being
Clinton Portis' 33 more yards, and the biggest increase being LaDainian Tomlinson's 569 more
yards as he eclipsed the 2,000 total yard plateau for the first time in his illustrious career.
So six out of the eight RBs that fit the criteria in recent years actually gained more yards,
impressive.
How about TDs? Clinton Portis had fewer TDs as he recorded 14, down three from his rookie
year total of 17. I'd take 14 any year. Willis McGahee had a significant drop of eight from
13 down to five, which coincided with the pitiful Ravens offense in 2005. The other four RBs
all increased their TD scoring prowess with Ricky Williams making the biggest jump of seven
from two to nine, and Edgerrin James scoring an impressive 18 in his second season, up only
one from his almsot as impressive rookie total of 17.
Maybe there is a link between the missed time and the number of touches they had in their
rookie season. The two who had the most touches were LaDainian TOmlinson and Edgerrin James.
Both players played all 16 games both seasons and both players saw their touches, yards and
TDs increase in their second seasons. The two RBs with the most touches after James and
Tomlinson were Jamal Lewis and Fred Taylor, so there is a trend there, but Tomlinson and
James should keep you from overcommitting to that trend.
So taking a second year RB with all the success and carries that Matt Forte (as well as Chris
Johnson and Steve Slaton) had last year seems as good a bet as any in this league. Injuries
strike all the time, and that 25% chance of a player producing less in his second season
seems like even less risk than you take drafting RBs with more experience. Forte is still
going second overall in my league.